“ It's a cold and snowy evening and just wanted a warm place to eat and have a lavation. The weather had kept most sane folks in so plenty of easy parking. Also means I got to be seated anywhere I wanted. I opted to sit at the bar. The bartender was very nice and well versed in the restaurants menu. She also made an excellent Old Fashioned. I had the burger with American cheese and everything else with the fires. It was delicious. Great time, great food. Great to be back as it has been apparently four years since my last visit as the restaurant burned and has been rebuilt and celebrated its one year anniversary. ”

“ Let me tell y'all something. If you're ever in this area of WV this place is a MUST go to! The best sandwiches I've ever had. The service was amazing, the inside was super sleek and clean. The food and everything about it tasted, looked, smelled and was fresh! I got the Rose Marie sandwhich with the chips and a side salad with melon ceaser dressing. The chips were some of the best house made chips I've had. They were super crunch and not soggy at all. The turkey on the sandwhich tasted like Thanksgiving turkey, and was so moist. The bread was toasted amazingly as well! Highly highly recommend! ”

“ Incredible atmosphere, food, and service. We arrived at 8pm which was close to closing time. The young man was very friendly about seating us and our waitress was very attentive. We started with the chips and parm Brussels . Both were delish! Then, had the Delano and house salad.... We left more than satisfied and happy we stopped....... Fresh, scrumptious, and different!! ”

“ Great stop during a light snow fall. Love the new building setup! Easy to "find" and plenty of parking. I ordered the Rose Marie and my wife selected the Fillmore. We knew going in to save half our sandwiches for dinner at our hotel that night as we traveled further north that afternoon. The service was quick and everything was delivered at the same time. Loved the warm sandwich on this chilly day. All in with tip was $43 ”

“ Highly recommend this hidden John that I found during a visit to new River Gorge national Park. The Truman sandwich is incredible with flavor, combinations of peach jam, blue cheese, and turkey. The customer service was incredible and I enjoyed one of the local lager as well. Will definitely be returning again and again. ”

“ I'm so glad Secret Sandwich Society reopened! It's my second go-to dinner option when in Fayetteville. The first being Pies and Pints. I usually get the Velvet Burger, which comes with bacon, French onion dip, balsamic onions, and swiss cheese and also fries. It's always very tasty and satisfying. I also tried their wings, made buffalo style. It was okay. They only gave us drums. This restaurant gets packed on the weekends. We showed up on a Saturday night and it was a 50 minute wait so we opted for take-out to eat on their patio. It was still about a 40-minute wait for food. They need to get heat lamps for the patio. ”

“ I love Secret Sandwich Society! Arrived on a Saturday afternoon at 4 to a 35 minute wait for a table but my party of two was able to squeeze into two bar stools. We were quickly sipping beer and reading the menu and both of the two attentive bartenders checked in with us regularly. We started with toasted Brussels Sprouts with feta, hot honey and balsamic. They were packed with a perfect blend of flavors and I will be trying to replicate the dish at my next holiday dinner! We also had house made potato chips with pimento cheese. Chips are addictive and while the cheese was pleasant, I generally chose to eat my chips with the Brussels Sprouts. Goodness! Such a great way to start a meal after having burned 4000 calories hiking at Nee River Gorge! For my sandwich, I ordered the Fillmore - vegan fried eggplant, roasted garlic mayo, provolone, red onions, cherry peppers & greens on a toasted baguette. Mm. Mmm. Mmmmm!! Eggplant was fried but not greasy. Garlic mayo was flavor abundant! Everything else provided a perfect compliment! Fries at SSS are great! Crisp, flavorful and no sogginess! I have been to both SSS outposts (Fayetteville, WV and Richmond, VA and throughly enjoyed both. Please expand more!! ”

“ So clever and creative This place gets all the stars We split a sammich and fries - it was shaved steak and it was SO SO GOOD. Plenty of parking Staff was lovely Restrooms very clean The bread was so good!!! ”

“ Probably my favorite meal of our vacation to the New River Gorge area! We came here for dinner last Saturday evening after a long day of exploring. This restaurant is right on the edge of downtown Fayetteville and hosts a spacious patio. They were busy on a Saturday (20-30 minute wait), but the hostess let us know we could sit and eat at the bar if we wished. There was no wait there, and so we did! I'm glad, too -- the bartender and our waitress (Lindsay, if I remember correctly?) was fantastic! The restaurant is pretty inside and has a modern and chic vibe. I loved it. The menu consists mostly of sandwiches and burgers but there are a lot of options and many of them are quite creative! They also have a good number of craft cocktails and beers. I was feeling like celebrating, so I asked Lindsay which of their cocktails was on the sweeter side since that is usually my preference. She recommended the BLT (blackberry, lemon, and thyme, mind you) shrub and so I ordered that and she made me one. Boy, she didn't steer me wrong. One of the better cocktails I've had in a very long time. Sweet, fruity, effervescent, strong but not cloying -- it was fantastic! For our meals, my parents split the Hoover (fried chicken sandwich), I got the Lady Bird (grilled chicken, bacon, chipotle mayo), and my husband got the Delano (fried fish). Hubs and I got fries while my parents had the house chips. My only major gripe about this place is our food took a pretty long time to come out. They were quite busy but it was still a little on the excessive side. Oh, and my husband's fish, while tasty, was a very thin and small cut of meat, which was disappointing to him. When our food did arrive, though, it was delish! I'm partial, but I think I got the best thing -- big, tender, juicy chicken breast, smoky bacon, slightly spicy and generous chipotle mayo, and fresh, crispy fries...it was a winner! My parents, who I could tell were skeptical when I recommended we go here, were also very pleased and devoured their half sandwiches. The house chips were great, too! My husband enjoyed the taste of his sandwich but like I said, was disappointed by the portion (especially compared to my and my parents' sandwiches). He agreed I outbought him. ;) Overall, I'd give my experience a 4.5 but don't think I quite would round up to a 5 due to the long wait for our orders. Still, I'd absolutely wholeheartedly recommend a visit here while in Fayetteville! ”